Low-carb, low-fat, high-protein, plant-based, Mediterranean: every few years a different eating pattern is crowned "the best diet for weight loss". Yet when researchers put diets head to head under controlled conditions, the winner is rarely as clear as the headlines suggest.
This article explains why. It looks at how energy needs are estimated, what diet composition actually changes, and why the most effective plan is usually the one you can live with.
Your energy needs are individual
Before comparing diets, it helps to know how much energy a body uses. In 2023, the US National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine published updated Dietary Reference Intakes for energy for the United States and Canada [1]. The new equations for estimated energy requirements were built from a large international database of doubly labelled water measurements, a gold-standard method that tracks energy expenditure in free-living people [1].
These equations account for age, sex, body size and composition, and physical activity level [1]. In other words, there's no universal calorie number. Two people of the same weight can have different needs, and one person's needs change with age, activity and weight loss itself.
This is the first reason a single "best diet" doesn't exist: the starting point is different for everyone.
Do carbs, fat and protein affect how much we eat?
Macronutrients aren't identical when it comes to appetite. A 2023 review of diet composition and energy intake in humans concluded that protein, carbohydrate and fat affect satiety, or how much we go on to eat, in the order protein > carbohydrate > fat [2].
But there's an important nuance. When the energy density of foods (calories per gram) is equalised, the differences between fat and carbohydrate are only modest [2]. Energy density is lowered mainly by water and raised mainly by fat. When researchers covertly increased the energy density of meals, with fat, carbohydrate or both, people ate more energy and gained weight [2].
The same review highlighted considerable individual variability in how people respond [2]. It also pointed out that today's food environment, full of cheap, highly palatable, energy-dense foods that mix fats and carbohydrates, influences intake through reward, habits and emotions as well as physiology [2].
What happens when diets go head to head?
Controlled feeding studies let scientists test whether diet composition changes energy expenditure and fat loss when calories are held constant. A meta-analysis of 32 such studies found that lower-fat diets led to slightly greater energy expenditure (about 26 kcal per day) and fat loss (about 16 g, or roughly 0.6 oz, per day) than lower-carbohydrate diets with the same calories [3]. That runs against the popular idea that cutting carbs "unlocks" fat burning, but the differences are small: a few dozen calories and grams per day.
In everyday settings, results look similar. A meta-analysis of 23 randomised trials with 2,788 participants compared low-carbohydrate diets (45% of energy or less from carbohydrate) and low-fat diets (30% of energy or less from fat) and found no significant difference between them for weight loss or waist circumference [4]. Both approaches improved metabolic risk factors, each with slightly different effects on blood lipids [4].
So the evidence doesn't point to one macronutrient ratio that works best for everyone. It points to a smaller set of factors that matter more: total energy, food quality, and whether you can keep it up.
Food quality and processing matter
One factor that cuts across almost every diet is ultra-processing. In a tightly controlled inpatient trial, 20 adults lived in a research unit for four weeks and ate an ultra-processed diet for two weeks and an unprocessed diet for two weeks [5]. The meals offered were matched for calories, energy density, macronutrients, sugar, sodium and fibre, and people could eat as much or as little as they wanted.
On the ultra-processed diet, participants ate about 508 kcal more per day and gained about 0.9 kg (2 lb). On the unprocessed diet, they lost about 0.9 kg (2 lb) [5].
That suggests a helpful common thread: whatever your preferred style of eating, building it mostly around minimally processed foods tends to make it easier to eat in line with your needs.
Why the "best diet" is the one you can sustain
If diet composition matters less than once believed, what makes a plan work? The research above points to a few practical principles:
- Energy balance still sets the direction. Controlled studies show total intake has a far larger effect on body fat than the carb-to-fat ratio [3].
- Satiety helps. Including protein and lower-energy-dense foods such as vegetables, fruit, legumes and soups can make it easier to feel satisfied on fewer calories [2].
- Individual response varies. Some people find low-carb easier, others prefer lower fat or a Mediterranean-style pattern [2, 4].
- Consistency beats perfection. A plan you can follow most days, around family meals, work and culture, will usually outperform a "perfect" plan you abandon after a few weeks.
Rather than asking "What is the best diet?", a more useful question is "Which way of eating can I keep up, enjoy, and adjust as I learn?"
Practical takeaways
- Energy needs depend on age, sex, body size and composition, and activity, so there's no universal calorie target [1].
- Protein tends to be the most satiating macronutrient, and energy density strongly affects how much we eat [2].
- In controlled studies, low-fat and low-carb diets with equal calories lead to very similar fat loss [3, 4].
- Ultra-processed diets led people to eat about 508 kcal more per day in a controlled trial [5].
- The best diet for weight loss is one built on whole foods that you can sustain over time.
Find the approach that fits you
Sustainable change comes from small, repeatable choices that suit your life. Viivaa helps you build healthy habits one small step at a time, so progress feels steady and sustainable.
This article is for general information only and isn't medical advice. If you have a medical condition, take medication or are planning a significant change to your diet, please talk to your doctor or a registered dietitian.
References
- National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine. Dietary Reference Intakes for Energy. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press; 2023. https://doi.org/10.17226/26818
- James Stubbs R, Horgan G, Robinson E, Hopkins M, Dakin C, Finlayson G. Diet composition and energy intake in humans. Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci. 2023;378(1888):20220449. https://doi.org/10.1098/rstb.2022.0449
- Hall KD, Guo J. Obesity energetics: body weight regulation and the effects of diet composition. Gastroenterology. 2017;152(7):1718โ1727.e3. https://doi.org/10.1053/j.gastro.2017.01.052
- Hu T, Mills KT, Yao L, et al. Effects of low-carbohydrate diets versus low-fat diets on metabolic risk factors: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled clinical trials. Am J Epidemiol. 2012;176(Suppl 7):S44โS54. https://doi.org/10.1093/aje/kws264
- Hall KD, Ayuketah A, Brychta R, et al. Ultra-processed diets cause excess calorie intake and weight gain: an inpatient randomized controlled trial of ad libitum food intake. Cell Metab. 2019;30(1):67โ77.e3. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cmet.2019.05.008