"I'm going to eat healthier." Most of us have set that goal, often more than once. The intention is real. But when it's 7 pm, you're tired and the fridge is nearly empty, the goal doesn't tell you what to do.
That gap between intending and doing is one of the most researched problems in behaviour science. Two strategies stand out in the evidence: monitoring your progress and if-then planning. Here is what the research shows, and how to put both to work.
Why good intentions aren't enough
Psychologists Peter Gollwitzer and Paschal Sheeran describe the problem directly: holding a strong goal doesn't guarantee reaching it, because people can struggle with the practical challenges that come up along the way [2]. Common obstacles include:
- Not starting, because the right moment passes unnoticed.
- Getting derailed by distractions, temptations or habits.
- Running out of steam when effort and willpower are low.
A broad goal like "eat healthier" leaves all of these decisions to the moment, which is usually when we're least equipped to make them.
Strategy 1: Keep track of your progress
A 2016 meta-analysis in Psychological Bulletin pulled together 138 studies with 19,951 participants in which people were randomly assigned either to an intervention that encouraged them to monitor their progress toward a goal or to a comparison group [1].
The findings [1]:
- The interventions were very effective at getting people to monitor their progress more often.
- They also improved goal attainment, and the increase in monitoring helped explain why.
- Monitoring had a larger effect when the results were physically recorded (for example, written down) or when they were reported to others or made public.
The authors concluded that monitoring goal progress is an effective self-regulation strategy [1]. In short: noticing where you are compared with where you want to be helps you close the gap.
Strategy 2: Make an if-then plan
An implementation intention is a plan that spells out when, where and how you'll act, in an "if-then" format [2]:
> If situation Y happens, then I will do X.
Instead of "I'll snack less", it becomes: "If I get home hungry at 6 pm, then I'll have yoghurt and fruit before I start cooking."
How well does it work?
Gollwitzer and Sheeran's 2006 meta-analysis combined 94 independent tests involving more than 8,000 participants [2]. Forming an if-then plan had a positive effect of medium-to-large size on reaching goals (d = 0.65), compared with having the goal alone [2].
The authors found that if-then plans helped people to [2]:
- Get started on their goals.
- Shield their goals from unwanted influences.
- Disengage from approaches that weren't working.
- Conserve capacity for future goals.
They also found evidence for why it works: making the plan made the chosen situation easier to notice, and made the planned response more automatic [2]. The decision has already been made, so you don't have to rely on willpower in the moment.
What makes if-then plans work for healthy eating?
A 2019 meta-regression in Appetite looked specifically at eating, analysing 70 interventions with 9,689 participants [3].
- For promoting healthy eating behaviours, if-then plans had a medium effect (d = 0.33) [3].
- For reducing unhealthy eating, the effect was small (d = 0.18) [3].
So if-then plans appear more effective at adding healthy behaviours than at cutting out unhealthy ones [3]. That's a useful insight: it may be easier to plan what to do than what not to do.
For healthy eating, the researchers also identified features linked to stronger effects [3]:
- Specific, simple plans: clear if-then and action plans worked better than complex plans.
- Initial training in how to form plans.
- Offline delivery, rather than online.
- Younger age, with effects tending to be larger in younger people.
Two findings were less intuitive. Effects were smaller when an instructor checked the plan, and smaller in student samples than in non-student groups [3]. One reasonable reading is that plans work best when they're genuinely your own, though the study wasn't designed to test why.
Practical takeaways: if-then templates you can use
Pick one or two plans to start. Keep them simple and specific [3], and focus on adding a healthy behaviour where you can [3].
How to write your own: first, pick the moment where your goal usually slips (the if). Make it a specific time, place or feeling you'll recognise. Then choose one concrete action you can take in that moment (the then). Read it back and ask: would I know exactly what to do?
Templates:
- If I sit down to lunch, then I'll fill half my plate with vegetables first.
- If I get home hungry, then I'll have a piece of fruit and a glass of water before I cook.
- If it's Sunday afternoon, then I'll plan three dinners for the week.
- If I want something sweet after dinner, then I'll have yoghurt with berries.
- If I'm at the supermarket, then I'll go to the fruit and vegetable section first.
- If I'm offered seconds, then I'll wait ten minutes and check whether I'm still hungry.
Make it stick:
- Write it down where you'll see it. Physically recording progress was linked to larger effects, and putting the plan on paper is a natural first step [1].
- Track how it goes. A simple tick each day you followed the plan is a form of progress monitoring [1].
- Share it if that helps you. Reporting progress to others was linked to larger effects [1].
- Adjust rather than abandon. If-then plans can help you let go of approaches that aren't working [2]. If a plan isn't fitting your life, rewrite it.
Building habits that last
The best plan is one small enough to follow on a busy day. Viivaa helps you build these healthy habits one small step at a time, so progress feels steady and sustainable.
This article is for general information only and isn't medical advice. If you have a medical condition or specific dietary needs, please talk to your doctor or a registered dietitian before changing how you eat.
References
- Harkin B, Webb TL, Chang BP, et al. Does monitoring goal progress promote goal attainment? A meta-analysis of the experimental evidence. Psychol Bull. 2016;142(2):198โ229. https://doi.org/10.1037/bul0000025
- Gollwitzer PM, Sheeran P. Implementation intentions and goal achievement: a meta-analysis of effects and processes. Adv Exp Soc Psychol. 2006;38:69โ119. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0065-2601(06)38002-1
- Carrero I, Vilร I, Redondo R. What makes implementation intention interventions effective for promoting healthy eating behaviours? A meta-regression. Appetite. 2019;140:239โ247. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.appet.2019.05.024