← Back to blog
HEALTH

Overate Again? How to Get Back on Track Without the Guilt

Viivaa
· 5 min read
Smiling woman enjoying a relaxed breakfast of bread, avocado and fruit at home
Photo: PNW Production / Pexels

You had a plan, and then a birthday dinner, a stressful week or a late-night snack took you well past it. The next morning often brings a familiar voice: I've blown it, so what's the point?

That reaction is understandable, and it matters more than the extra food. Research on dietary lapses suggests that the way you respond to a slip can shape what happens next. Here is what the studies show, and how to use it.

Lapses are a normal part of changing how you eat

Researchers use the term dietary lapse for a specific instance of not sticking to your eating plan. A 2023 study in Appetite points out that lapses are common during weight-loss attempts and can undermine progress in two ways: they add calories, and they can be demoralising, sometimes to the point that people give up on their weight goals altogether [2].

The authors note that this second effect, demoralisation, has received almost no research attention [2]. Yet it's often the more important one. A single larger-than-planned meal rarely changes much on its own. Giving up on your plan for the next few weeks is what really costs progress.

So the goal isn't to never slip. It's to recover quickly when you do.

What self-compassion means here

Self-compassion can sound vague, but researchers define it in concrete terms. The 2023 Appetite study describes three parts [2]:

  • Self-kindness: treating yourself the way you would treat a friend.
  • Common humanity: recognising that everyone struggles.
  • Mindfulness: being aware of your thoughts and feelings without judging them.

It's not the same as letting yourself off the hook. The same study explains that self-compassion has potential to promote helpful responses to setbacks because it reframes "failure" and supports self-improvement [2].

What the research found

Study 1: Self-compassion, guilt and the intention to keep going

A 2021 study in the British Journal of Health Psychology followed 56 adults with overweight or obesity who were trying to lose weight by restricting their diet [1]. For two weeks, they answered short surveys on their phones twice a day. Whenever they reported a lapse, they were asked how they responded to it and how they felt [1].

On occasions when people responded to a lapse with more self-compassion than usual, they reported [1]:

  • Stronger intentions to continue with their diet.
  • Greater confidence (self-efficacy) that they could keep going.
  • Fewer negative emotional reactions to the lapse.

Feelings of guilt helped explain these links [1]. In this study, self-compassion did not predict weight loss itself [1], which is an important caveat. But the authors concluded that it may be a powerful internal resource when people face the inevitable setbacks of weight loss, and could help them persevere [1].

Study 2: Which part of self-compassion helps most?

The 2023 study looked more closely, with 140 adults in a behavioural weight-loss programme who completed six short surveys a day for a week [2].

  • Total self-compassion and each of its three parts were all linked to less negative mood after a lapse [2].
  • Self-compassion did not change the chance of having another lapse later that day [2].
  • Higher total self-compassion and higher self-kindness after a lapse were linked to greater perceived control over eating and weight-management behaviours in the following hours [2].
  • Common humanity and mindfulness on their own weren't linked to perceived control [2].

The authors suggested that self-compassion after a setback may help prevent people from abandoning their goals, and that self-kindness was the part most strongly linked to helpful responses [2].

What these studies can and can't tell us

Both studies were relatively small and observational, so they show associations rather than cause and effect. Neither found that self-compassion directly led to more weight loss. What they consistently suggest is that a kinder response to a slip is linked to staying engaged with your goals, and staying engaged is what makes long-term change possible.

Breakfast table with flowers in warm morning sunlight
Photo: Radis B / Pexels

Why harsh self-criticism backfires

If guilt and negative feelings help explain the link between self-compassion and giving up [1], it makes sense that beating yourself up isn't a reliable motivator. Harsh thoughts after overeating ("I have no willpower", "I always ruin it") tend to feed the what's the point thinking that turns one meal into a lost week.

A more useful question is: What would I say to a friend in this situation? Most of us would be honest but kind, and help them plan the next step. That's self-kindness, the part most strongly linked to perceived control in the 2023 study [2].

Practical takeaways: your get-back-on-track plan

  1. Name it as a lapse, not a failure. A lapse is one moment of not following your plan. It doesn't cancel your progress [2].
  2. Respond the way you'd respond to a friend. Try a sentence like: "That was a lot of food, and that's okay. Lots of people go through this. My next meal is a fresh start." This draws on self-kindness and common humanity [2].
  3. Notice the feeling without judging it. If you feel guilty, acknowledge it rather than arguing with it or acting on it. Lower guilt was part of how self-compassion was linked to better intentions [1].
  4. Go back to your normal next meal. Skip the urge to "make up for it" with a skipped meal or extreme restriction. Just return to your usual plan.
  5. Look for the trigger, calmly. Were you very hungry, tired or stressed? Was it a social event? Knowing the trigger helps you plan for next time.
  6. Make one small plan for next time. For example: "If I'm going to a dinner, I'll have a balanced lunch so I don't arrive starving."
  7. Remember what self-compassion doesn't do. It won't prevent every slip [2]. It may help you stay committed after one [1][2].

If episodes of overeating feel out of control, happen often, or come with intense distress, talk to your doctor. These can be signs of a condition that deserves proper support.

Building habits that last

Getting back on track is a skill, and like any skill it gets easier with practice. Viivaa helps you build these healthy habits one small step at a time, so progress feels steady and sustainable.

Discover Viivaa →

This article is for general information only and isn't medical advice. If you often feel out of control around food, or you have a history of an eating disorder, please talk to your doctor or a qualified mental health professional.

References

  1. Thøgersen-Ntoumani C, Dodos LA, Stenling A, Ntoumanis N. Does self-compassion help to deal with dietary lapses among overweight and obese adults who pursue weight-loss goals? Br J Health Psychol. 2021;26(3):767–788. https://doi.org/10.1111/bjhp.12499
  2. Hagerman CJ, Ehmann MM, Taylor LC, Forman EM. The role of self-compassion and its individual components in adaptive responses to dietary lapses. Appetite. 2023;190:107009. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.appet.2023.107009